Carolyn and I just saw the road revival of the 1964 musical Hello, Dolly! My life passed in front of my eyes.

Dolly Gallagher Levi is a matchmaker and hustling Jill-of-all-trades in 1885 New York. Widowed a decade, she sets her sights on Horace Vandergelder, a Yonkers widower and reputed half-a-millionaire. All the rest is commentary.

Except, who is Dolly? Originally Dolly Gallagher, she’s Irish. But she married a Jew, Ephraim Levi. (Ephraim was one of the biblical Joseph’s two sons, Levi Jacob’s third son and antecedent to Israel’s hereditary priests beginning with Aaron). The musical’s roots lie in Thornton Wilder’s play The Matchmaker. Making Dolly’s late, beloved husband a Jew seemed to have been a rather brave undertaking on Wilder’s part.

But, was Ephraim really Jewish? During a monologue by Dolly, we see the store Ephraim owned—a haberdashery—a men’s clothing store. In 1966, a Jewish-owned men’s store was the first thing I saw in Anniston, Alabama heading to Fort McClellan and advanced infantry training. And when Dolly is asked to name a great American, her reply: Moses!

In 2006, the Jewish actress Tovah Feldshuh decided not to play Dolly as Jewish because she herself was. The late Carol Channing, who originated the role, did play Dolly as Jewish “On the basis of my own early marriage right out of Bennington. I married into a Galician, Yiddish-speaking family.”

Which brings me to me. Actually, to my wife. Carolyn was raised in Waco as a Catholic but had many Jewish friends and a Jewish aunt, uncle and cousin. She was falling away from Catholicism when we met. No, she never converted. A justice of the peace married us. 

But over the last 50 years (this September marks our golden anniversary), she’s been a true helpmate to a Jewish man, raised three Jewish children, supported our synagogue and championed Israel, which we’ve visited together twice. I should add that she often enlightens her friends (many or most Jewish) on Jewish practices and Israel.

This may be due in part to my parents, Morris and Blanche, who welcomed Carolyn into the family sight unseen. Of course, my mother had to meet this girl after we called from San Antonio to say we were getting married. A sophisticated woman with perfect hair, makeup, nails, clothing and accessories, Blanche Perlstein flew down and brought gifts—among them a potato grater and jar of chicken fat.

It was love at first sight. My mother signed me over to Carolyn as Dolly Levi gave Horace Vandergelder no choice but to marry her. Carolyn has “guided” my life, clarifying what I really wanted to do about various things because how could I be expected to make decisions about the menu at our kids’ b’nai mitzvah or our 36th (double chai/2×18) recommitment ceremony at Congregation Sherith Israel, or the colors for the exterior of our house.

Doubtless, Ephraim Levi knew how lucky he was to marry Dolly Gallagher. I feel the same way about Carolyn. So does my entire family, who from the outset made Carolyn their own while relegating me to “Carolyn’s husband.”

Without Carolyn, I’d be nothing. So from now on, I’ll refer to Hello, Dolly! as Shalom, Dolly! because the moment I met Carolyn, I said hello to a better life.  

To respond, click on “comments” to the right just below the title of this post. Then go to the response space at the bottom of the post.


  1. Penelope De Paoli on March 15, 2019 at 5:47 pm

    What a wonderful love poem to Carolyn. May the rest of your days together be as wonderful.

    • David on March 15, 2019 at 6:05 pm

      Thank you, Penny. The next 50 years should prove interesting.

  2. Carolyn Power Perlstein on March 15, 2019 at 6:38 pm

    And I am blessed to love you & to be loved by you all the days of our lives.

  3. Tracy on March 15, 2019 at 7:43 pm

    And of course, I will point out that the original Dolly, Carol Channing, is a Lowellite and the school theatre is named after her. I “starred” as Tony in West Side Story in that very place.

    Not a jar of schmaltz, but still….

    • David on March 15, 2019 at 9:39 pm

      Tracy. I’m sensing a great deal of schmaltz. And Lowell has truly been a great high school.

  4. Aaron on March 18, 2019 at 6:21 pm

    This was a delight to read – and as anyone who’s every met the two of you knows, you are the perfect match. As your youngest son, I can only hope that my marriage with Jeremy grows to the same heights that yours has when we reach our own golden anniversary – a mere 43 years away. Mazel Tov!

    • David on March 18, 2019 at 8:53 pm

      Ah, the things we learn about our parents. May you have a joyous 50th as we’re planning.

Leave a Comment